| Page | Subject | Notes |
| 3 | contributors | Russ Sears (not Russell); Thomas Casper, Raymond Callan, Jeff Ambio, John Esterly, Brian Koller, Bill Groom, John Mutch, Edward Shafer, Tim Webb. This page will need to be rewritten, SC4 committee, contributors, etc. |
| 10 | n iron | change -23n to -20n. |
| 11 | | last paragraph - torepresent should be two words. |
| 12 | "classes of tokens" | Class D is broad enough to bring in all sorts of pre-Civil War tokens. Fix or delist this NC stuff. Do we even need this discussion of "classes" of tokens? |
| 25 | die sinker/engravers | insert text about Kleinsteuber - SC4 word file |
| 35 | die photos | remove 1023A (this is actually 1031) ----- SH: "Actually to me this is what we used to call 1039A that is the most common reverse on the Atlas Michigan token what we used to call MI045A-5a which is no longer listed I have been calling R7 but likely more available when published." |
| 36 | die photos | replace 1031 photo with the one that was 1023A. In my SCB3 photos file as the "true 1031" |
| 38 | die photos emailed Bill 12/18/23 | add 1086A - see emails from Bill Luitje & Scott Blinkensderfer 3/15/19. Bill expressed doubt about a month later. Pics of "IN460S-2a" with that reverse d/n demonstrate a different reverse. Looks identical to -1a. Looks to me like this purported 1086 or 1086A is just a worn example of 1084. |
| 41 | die photos | add 1150B which is paired with PA-750E in brass |
| 41 | die photos | QDB reports 1138 is actually two different dies. New one would be 1138A. I have pic of "1138A" and email from QDB Mar 8, 2018. I don't see a difference. Thinner ribbon? Maybe someone can help. |
| 46 | die photos | replace current photo with the one now named 1238. Wayne Stafford says wrong pic. SC3's pic is Pat 234 and slightly different. Have correct photo now dated 1/2/16. |
| 46 | die photos | remove 1250B. Not in use by any CWT. |
| 49 | die photos | remove 1289 (this is now die 32035) |
| 54 | die photos | add 1398A, new 25 reverse used with LU-Town Branch Store |
| 61 | die photos | 1019, 1020, and 1021 should read 13th star, not 12th |
| 62 | die photos | p.62 - Higgins - (1049-1050A). Remove the 1051 line. |
| 62 | die photos-emailed Bill 12/18/23 | add 1086A? - see emails from Bill Luitje & Scott Blinkensderfer 3/15/19. To me the way to ID is no LUTZ (higher grade tokens) and Liberty's eye toward 10th star on 1084 and between 10 & 11th stars on 1086A, but is it just a worn die? |
| 64 | die hints | see SC4 word file. |
| 65 | die hints | remove 1250B. Not in use by any CWT. |
| 70 | Renner's List | remove reference to 1023A ----- See comments above. I believe Steve Tanenbaum had what he called OH830C-9b with what he called a 1023A reverse. It was in a slab so perhaps NGC can supply a photo, they graded VF35. I saw it but don't recall any specifics but I valued at $300 retail so I must have thought it was something of value. |
| 70-85 | Renner's List | LU references use a numeric convention that was abandoned. Fix all. Fixes will be in SC4 word file. Probably wait until all adds/deletes/moves are identified. |
| 70-85 | Renner's List | This will all need updating due to new varieties. Added die 1086A (IN460S-2a). Removed dies -1023A, 1250B, 1289. Added 1398A. |
| 79 | Die 1188 | Only use is IL150R. There are some stray die numbers in there. |
| 84 | die 1419 | remove OH-165BZ |
| 87 | AL-425A-12d | new variety -1018 reverse, CN, reeded edge, R10. |
| 88 | CT-035A-2j | obverse s/b 20110 |
| 89 | CT-250A-1fp | these are nickel plated per conversation with Ernie 6/9/17 and later verified by NGC. |
| 90 | CT-345aA-1ao | flipover double strike. New variety. Hayden 47 |
| 90 | CT-345aA-7ao | City of New York/Bode 29450/29200 over an 1849 Large Cent. |
| 92 | D.C. | Place a blue box: District of Columbia - see Hard Rubber token section. |
| 93 | Idaho | remove this section and place the ID token in the possible CWT section and leave behind a marker? |
| 96 | IL-095A | Name in all caps in header needs to be fixed. |
| 98 | IL-150G-4a | R10-reverse 1108. Pl edge. Reported by QDB 4/18/18. |
| 100 | IL-150Ma | R10. PL. Call obv/rev: 20407/0. See SC4 word file for write-up |
| 108 | IL-150AS-2a | change obverse to 20830. |
| 109 | IL-150AX | change header to Henry from "N. Henry". John Mutch caught that the address is N. Wells 3/16/20. |
| 110 | IL-150BB | need a die explosion for the two pictures 20880/20890. 20890 has a comma after Siehler. |
| 112 | IL-215A-2d | R10 unlisted composition. Plain edge. |
| 112 | IL-220A-1d | change rarity to NV |
| 112 | IL-220A-2d | R10 unlisted composition. reeded edge. |
| 114 | IL-320E | a couple of varieties are listed as 320A. Correct to E. |
| 114 | IL-320E-1ao4 | R9 over WI-510AD-1a - reported by Larry D. and also by Bill Luitje; also one sold on eBay 3/22, ex: Tanenbaum |
| 118 | IL-690A-5d | reverse should be 1047 |
| 120 | IL-692A | pics for 10130 & 10140 should be reversed. Have pics in SC3 folder as these numbers with notes. |
| 121 | IL-692A-2m | call this -2e. Remove reference to full broackage. Hayden sold one Dec 2019 |
| 121 | IL-692A-2n | remove reference to being full brockage. Change rarity to NV. |
| 120 | IL-692A-7fo | new variety R10 PL (over a Chile 1846 1 real) (have pics) |
| 120 | IL-692A-12 | obv: 34070 |
| 120 | IL-692A-13 | obv: 34070 for all metals |
| 120 | IL-692A-16d | new variety. R10? At least R9. Reeded edge? |
| 120 | IL-692A-20e | Change rarity to R9. |
| 120 | IL-692A-20n | R10. PL. 10110/10110 inc |
| 120 | IL-692A-21a | 10140/34050, reeded edge. Ex: Bowers, Hayden 48 (1869 obv -true 10140). 10140 is terminal die state. Change rarity to R9. |
| 120 | IL-692A-21d | 10140/34050, reeded edge. Ex: Bowers, Hayden 48 (1869 obv -true 10140). 10140 is much earlier die state than copper version. |
| 120 | IL-692A-23n | kill. Same as -2m. |
| 120 | IL-692A-24d | 10140/1047 R-10. (1069 die - terminal die state). 1047 early die state. When was this struck and what does this say about 1047 die state V examples??? |
| 120 | IL-692A-25a | 34070/1037. R10 Reeded edge. Hayden 48 (incorr slabbed as -18a) |
| 120 | IL-692A-26a | 34050/28850. R10 PE. Unlisted muling with AM Johnston, Buffalo. Pics from Tim Webb 10/22. |
| 120 | IL-692 | need to scrub this entire section after completion to make sure this is right. YR is a pain in the rear, especially with all the new varieties. |
| 121 | IL-755A | all varieties should be plain edge |
| 122 | IL-762A-2d | Reeded edge R10 21300/1047 |
| 123 | IL-775B | Header should just have druggist. That's why it is listed separately from the banker. |
| 123 | IL-775B | move the note about the mispelling in the comments on 755B to 755A and change wording from B-2a to A-2a. |
| 123 | IL-795A-3a | change rarity rating to R9 |
| 124 | IL-890B-2 | 21 mm. Only the -2 varieties. The -1b is 19mm. |
| 126 | IN-005A-1ao | struck over IN-780B-1a |
| 130 | IN-140A-7a | PL edge. |
| 135 | IN-200A | move former LU-I info here. Crawfordsville, IN. Change narrative (see SC4 Word file). Add box for Crawfordsville like we have for other cities. |
| 136 | IN-260C-2a | rarity change to NV. |
| 137 | IN-280C & D | Remove language that this is a new listing for the third edition. |
| 137 | IN-280D-1e | change header to "Mertens & Krueger" |
| 146 | IN-460B-4d | R10. rev: 1047 reeded edge. Stacks sale of QDB inv Oct 2020. |
| 150 | IN-460N | die currently labeled as 22380 should be labeled 22410 |
| 152 | IN-460S-2a | Add. Rev 1086A. R-8?. Let's make sure this truly is a new variety. |
| 153 | IN-460V-3 | -3 varieties should have reverse die 1436 |
| 157 | IN-500H-1a/b | Delete listing. Examined by NGC and again by QDB and identified as -1b. |
| 159 | IN-500P-1do | R10. plain edge, over CN cent. Hayden 48. |
| 160 | IN-510C | kill the part in the narrative about the first initial being incorrect. |
| 166 | IN-570E narrative | reference to -1a and -2b should be to -1a and -2a |
| 168 | IN-580B | photo labeled 23100 should be labeled 23120 |
| 170 | IN-630A-12b1 | Reeded edge R10. Reported by QDB 2/27/18. |
| 170 | IN-630A-14b | obv should be 23210 |
| 170 | IN-630B | photos of dies 23230 and 23240 should be reversed (23240 currently labeled as 232340) |
| 170 | IN-630B-1b | rarity change to NV |
| 172 | IN-710A-2ao | remove listing. Erroneous listing per Steve Hayden, Auction #46 Lot 248, April 2018 |
| 172 | IN-715A-2b | Should be -1b. |
| 172 | IN-740B-6ao | R10 flip over double strike. Sold by Hayden 7/22 |
| 172 | IN-740B-7a | reverse should be 40962 (not 23320) |
| 173 | IN-740C | die label should be 23340 |
| 173 | IN-760B-2a | obverse die should be 23360 (not 23350) |
| 174 | IN-770C-4d | obverse die should be 23420 (not 23410) |
| 175 | IN-800A | Change narrative - see SC4 word file. |
| 177 | IN-860B-1i | R9. Plain edge, reported by QDB 11/30/18. |
| 179 | IN-870A-5a | Change to R9. Confirmed to exist by Bill Luitje email 1/18/21. |
| 180 | IN-900A-1b | should be -1bo |
| 180 | IN-930A-3b | New listing with 1391A reverse, reeded edge. QDB sale May 2019. Actually don't have to do anything - NC section. |
| 182 | IA-150A-2a | 23730/1105 |
| 182 | IA-150A-3a | 23720/1205. Change rarity to R-9 |
| 185 | KY-150Ba | Crittenden Shades (propr: D.W. Egleston). Found in the 1866 Covington CD and listed as a saloon in the business directory. No CDs for Covington 62-65. Move all listings of OH165AF here and change occupation to saloon. Rewrite of the intro in SC4 word file. |
| 185 | KY-150Ba | Crittenden Shades. Change diameter from 25 to 19. |
| 186 | KY-480A-3b | Should be 19mm not 22mm. |
| 186 | KY-480B-1d | R10, reeded edge |
| 188 | KY-510Ga | move LU-J listings to here from page 611 and remove from LU section. T. Johnston |
| 188 | KY-510I | header should read H.B. Opfeld |
| 188 | KY-510J-1f | change NV to R10. |
| 190 | KY-510O-1fo | change edge to PL (confirmed by QDB 10/4/17) |
| 191 | KY 640B-7a | R10. PL. UNL composition. Heritage 8/21. |
| 191 | KY 640C-6a | R10. PL. UNL composition. Stacks 4/23. |
| 191 | KY 640C-8a | R10. PL. UNL composition. Heritage 4/21. |
| 194-203 | MD-060 | see SC4 Word file for new intro. |
| | retaining only MD-060E, J, W, Y, AK. Removing all other listings. May need to add a few initial tokens. |
| 198 | MD-060O | remove the header "fka as IL150Wa" |
| 198 | MD-060T-1b | R9 or even R8. See notes below - SC4 committee needs to decide what to do with all of these MD counterstamps. |
| 198 | MD-060T-1b | picture is labeled 70110. Should be 70155. |
| 199 | MD-060Wa-1b | S. N/ 5 (unlisted in SC3 - have pics)- will need to update preface to MD060 to address this token that uses 1001 |
| 201 | MD-060AGa? | F.C.S. (lot 20422 Stacks Mar 2020) Rev 1352A. |
| 201 | MD-060AHa? | P. SCH (unlisted in SC3 - have pics)-will also need to update preface to MD060. This token reverse is 1296A. |
| 202 | MD-060AJ | insert a short narrative |
| 202 | MD-060AK | Some changes needed on write-up. QDB found the Shakespeare Club in an 1866 newspaper announcement. |
| 203 | MD-060AQ | picture/die 70420 is wrong (if we even list these) |
| 206 | MA-115D-2a | R9. Have sales records for 2 distinct examples. |
| 209 | MA-260A-3f | 24380/42060 (reverse is obverse of RI-700E), Reported by QDB 4/18/18. |
| 210 | MA-530A | 24mm instead of 23. |
| 211 | MA-760B-1e | probably should be called -1m (tin). NGC has begun slabbing as such in 2017. Musante's book says tin, not white metal. Will need to add a note. |
| 211 | MA-760B-1(fp)? | Have pics of what might be a silver plated copper example. Need to send through NGC or something. Not in Musante's book and that is suspicious. |
| 213 | MI-005A | picture label s/b 24435 |
| 214 | MI-005B | picture label s/b 24440 |
| 217 | MI-040B-3j | should be listed after -3do, out of order |
| 217 | MI-040C | Comments-don't need to mention the "I". Remove sentence. |
| 218 | MI-045A-5a | 1039A? We don't even have that stock die. In my sales database, but no notes in SC3 discussions that I can find. Email from Dave Reineri 2/27/17-explains that 1039A was probably 1023A (now 1031) which is 45A-2a. No need to do anything. |
| 220 | MI-085B-3b | change rarity rating to NV |
| 223 | MI-190A-4a | 24820/24820. Remove language about full brockage. (Hayden auction 44 Dec 16). This be the actual -3a? Could both -2a and -3a be struck and not incuse? Hayden remarks that he has not seen -2a or -3a. |
| 224 | MI-225A-10d | R10, 1046 reverse. Reeded edge. 24587/1046. Steve Hayden sold on eBay 10/25/20. Mislabeled in a PCGS slab as -1d, ex: Bowers. |
| 225 | MI-225E-4i | R9 reeded edge. missing |
| 227 | MI-225J-3d | R9 |
| 227 | MI-225L-2a1 | R10 plain edge. Hayden 47 from Tanenbaum collection. |
| 231 | MI-225T-4d | R9. Temple example and Bowers example (ex: Curtis) |
| 232 | MI-225X-1a1 | R10 plain edge. Hayden 47 from Tanenbaum collection. |
| 236 | MI-225AGa- | Oliver Goldsmith (fka LU-G) move all listings from LU-G to here and delete from LU section. |
| 238 | MI-225AO-5d | correct obv die to 25340 |
| 238 | MI-225AO-6a1 | R9 |
| 239 | MI-225AQ-1a1 | R9 per Bill Luitje email 8/11/20. |
| 241 | MI-225AY-1a1 | R9 (at least two examples known) |
| 241 | MI-225AZ | listings are messed up. -2a s/b 1a1, then 2a-2i = 1042, 3a & 3d = 1047 |
| 241 | MI-225AZ-1a1 | R10 currently -2a and should be PL edge |
| 243 | MI-225BE-1a1 | R9 plain edge new variety confirmed by Bill Luitje |
| 244 | MI-225BI-3b1 | R9 plain edge new variety sold by Steve Hayden 11/21 eBay |
| 244 | MI-225BJ | All obverse dies and die label should be 25560 (not 25550) |
| 247 | MI-225BR-3a | edge s/b 'R' |
| 251 | MI-225CG-1d | reverse should be 1018. Verified by Bill Luitje upon examination of a Heritage lot; see email 8/31/17. |
| 253 | MI-225CJa | Eben s/b Eber |
| 256 | MI-225CS-1d | R10 CN reeded edge. Stacks sale 10/20 QDB inv where it was incorrectly slabbed as -3d. |
| 256 | MI-225CS-3a | Delete listing. Email from Steve Hayden. Listing came from belief this was in the Temple collection. It wasn't. |
| 258 | MI-280D-1a1 | R10 plain edge. Hayden 47 from Tanenbaum collection. |
| 259 | MI-300C-1b/a | R10 PL But do we list these b/a or a/b tokens? |
| 260 | MI-300D | picture label s/b 26130 |
| 260 | MI-300E | Change box to Aaron Mest. (see CWTSJ V50N3). Add sentence to intro: Mest's name is misspelled on the token. |
| 261 | MI-360C-1f | change rarity from NV to R9. A NGC slabbed example on ebay 3/17. Seen 2. |
| 265 | MI-370L-4a | Unlisted variety. New obverse 26725. Have pic. Reverse is 1211. R9 PL. Need a "die explosion". From Hayden#42 Aug 2015 sold as L-3a, reported by Brian Koller 8/15. Compare "C" in MICH. Other differences, but this is easiest to distinguish. |
| 265 | MI-450A | unlisted obverse (have pic) -- call it 26745. Per the pics at SH's website - the -1a and -1b are 26745/1185 and -2b is 26740/1187. Need a die explosion. New obv has a comma after Hillsdal. |
| 267 | MI-450F | header: Jaob should be Jacob |
| 268 | MI-450L | change intro. See SC4 word file |
| 269 | MI-450O | change intro. See SC4 word file |
| 274 | MI-527C-1b | Add this listing: 27180/1185. R-9 PL. Verified by NGC, ebay listing pointed out by Bill Luitje. He is of the opinion that -3b may not exist. Have pic of -1b and that is right. |
| 279 | MI-580B-2d | R10 PL. 1105 Temple collection |
| 287 | MI-865A-4a | R9+. See discussion involving QDB, Steve Hayden, Bill Luitje, et al late March/early April 2019. New obv & rev: 27826 & 27827? Is this truly a new variety or a fake? |
| 287 | MI-865A-5a | purported new variety. Have pics 3/20. |
| 294 | MO-910A | Remove reference to Darwin Peck. That's the previous token that got repeated. |
| 294 | MO-910A-2b | R10 unlisted composition PL edge |
| 294 | MO-910A-2i | reduce rarity rating from R9 to R8 |
| 294 | MO-910A-5d | R10 unlisted composition, Reeded edge |
| 294 | MO-910A-8d | R10 unlisted. 1069 rev Reeded edge |
| 294 | MO-910B | header has MN. Cahnge to MO. |
| 294 | MO-910B-8a | R10 obv 28040; rev:1046A Reeded edge |
| 295 | MO-910C-1e | R10 unlisted composition, plain edge, Heritage June 2016, Hayden Dec 2016. |
| 299 | NJ-555C-1ao | R9 flipover doublestrike (sold by Hayden 11/21) |
| 299 | NJ-555C-7d | R10 unlisted composition, plain edge. |
| 300 | NJ-885A | -2a should be -1b. |
| 302 | NY-010A-3ao | R10. plain edge, flipover dbl strike, PCGS55, ex:Bowers |
| 302 | NY-010A-6ao | R10. plain edge, struck over NY630P. Stacks sale 10/20 of QDB inv. |
| 304 | NY-010F-1a1 | (struck on an oval planchet) R10 PL. QDB email 3/20/19. PCGS slabbed as -4a, if anything, it should be -2a or -1a1 since it is the same dies. |
| 305 | NY-010-G-3a | Unlisted new obverse: 28445, same reverse as others. R5 PL. Pic dated 7/6/18 on computer. |
| 305 | NY-010H-3b | R10, unlisted composition, plain edge |
| 305 | NY-010H-7b | R10, unlisted composition, plain edge |
| 306 | NY-010H-9ao | R9. Note underneath: (obverse over NY-890B partial brockage) |
| 306 | NY-010H-16a | Unlisted variety - 28540/28575. R-9 PL. email from Steve Hayden 5/6/20. |
| 307 | NY-077-4a | R10 - PL, obv: 28610/1108 QDB 8/2/19 |
| 308 | NY-095D-1j | reverse is 1006 (not 2006) |
| 309 | NY-095F-6a | new obverse die. 28722 rev 1269 PL. Need a "die explosion" pic for the two dies. Watch the alignment of the "LLs" in WILLIAMS v. the preceding 'I". Probably need a note that some varieties using the 28720 obverse die are actually this new die. -5a is known with both obverses. Have not seen the new obverse paired with anything other than 1269 to date, but... |
| 320 | NY-630G-2b | R-9, 27mm |
| 321 | NY-630Ha | George Lovett, not Robert Lovett in narrative |
| 321 | NY-630Hb | George Lovett, not Robert Lovett in narrative |
| 322 | NY-630-K | change all 23mm to 24mm, except the -9 varieties |
| 323 | NY-630K-9 | 19mm, not 23mm (only the -9 varieties with 1133 as reverse) |
| 324 | NY630L-4e | R7, not R5 |
| 324 | NY-630L-7do | R-9 PL (struck over 1863 C-N cent). Stacks 10/20 of QDB inv. |
| 325 | NY-630L | pics of dies 29310 & 29315 need to be reversed (and the die explosion) |
| 325 | NY-630L-11 | change rarity rating to NV |
| 325 | NY-630L-14do | R-9 PL. Struck over U.S. C-N cent. |
| 325 | NY-630L-19a | obv should be 29320 |
| 325 | NY-630L-20b | 29315/1065 plain edge. R9. Reported by Steve Hayden 12/13/17. On eBay 11/21. |
| 325 | NY-630L-21b | 29310/0 plain edge. R9. Reported by Steve Hayden 10/28/21. On eBay 11/21. |
| 328 | NY-630T-1bo | improve language to: (struck over DeWitt 1860-59). |
| 332 | NY-630AC-1b | R9 PL. New variety. |
| 333 | NY-630AE-1n | R10 PL. Reported by Bill Luitje 2/5/18. Metallurgical analysis - 81% iron, tin 16%., Hayden sale 12/22. |
| 334 | NY-630AG-7d | R8 PL. missing |
| 334 | NY-630AG-8d | R9 PL. missing |
| 335 | NY-630AIa-1a | R10 PL. Hayden sold one Mar 2022. Have pics |
| 335 | NY-630AIa-1b | R10 PL. Hayden 47 |
| 336 | NY-630AL-9a | R9 PL 29760/1217. New variety. Email from Tim Webb 8/18/23. |
| 337 | NY-630AN-1ao | R10 PL (struck over unknown token), Stacks Nov 2020. Confirmed by NGC to be copper but doesn't look like it. |
| 337 | NY-630AN-2ao1 | flipover double strike. New variety. |
| 338 | NY-630AP-1ao | R9 flipover double strike |
| 338 | NY-630AP-1do | R9 struck over 1863 cent reported by QDB 9/24/19 |
| 339 | NY-630AQ-4fo | Change struck over silver coin from Ecuador to- struck over 1821-BS 2 reales from Caracas, Venezuela. Reported by Mark Borckardt 9/15/20. |
| 345 | NY-630BC-1ao | change rarity to R-9. Also change description to struck over offset printing plate. |
| 345 | NY-630BC-1b1 | Change rarity to NV |
| 348 | NY-630BG-4bo | change to struck over 1137. PCGS63, ex: Bowers, slabbed as -4b. |
| 348 | NY-630BG-6g | R10 PL. QDB reported 5/25/19. |
| 349 | NY-630BI-2b | R10 PL. TC-557445 on TokenCatalog. Submitted by Steve Hayden. |
| 349 | NY-630BJ | Change 23mm to 24. |
| 349 | NY-630BJ-1fo1 | R10 PL (struck over 1858 Canadian 20 cent). Stacks 10/20 and Hayden 49 12/22. |
| 349 | NY-630BK-1bo | R10 PL. (struck over 2 drachm apothecary weight). Stacks Sep 2013 where it was called -5bo. Where have I seen this undertype? Have pics. |
| 350 | NY-630BM-1ao | R9 PL. (flipover double strike) |
| 352 | NY-630BS-1f | R-10 PL. new composition reported by Mark B. Heritage 6/16 |
| 353 | NY-630BU-3ao | R9. flipover double strike |
| 354 | NY-630BV-17 & 18 | Change obverse from 30460 to 30470 for all compositions. |
| 354 | NY-630BV-17 | Change reverse from 1006 to 1000 for all compositions. |
| 355 | NY-630BV-32 | Kill this. Once the above 2 changes are made, the variety in SC3 is superflous. |
| 355 | NY-630BV-33a | 34060/0. R10 PL. Ex: Fuld. In my sales file. |
| 355 | NY-630BX-1a | R9 PL. Unlisted in copper. Hayden sold one 2/21 on eBay. |
| 356 | NY-630BZ-1fo1 | R10 PL. (struck over a British West Indies 1/8 dollar) |
| 356 | NY-630BZ-3j | R9 PL. Missing |
| 357 | NY-630CA-1fo3 | R10 PL (struck over 1770 Mexico one real). Partrick sale Heritage lot 45998 5/21. |
| 359 | NY-630CF-2g | R-5 PL. second obverse. Need a die explosion. T in relationship to the O in store .email from Ed Shafer 8/20/20- |
| 359 | NY-630CFa-1z | R10 PL. Seen 6/20 in PCGS holder as -1i. Clearly zinc. Sold in Nov 2020 Stacks sale. |
| 363 | NY-780A-1ao | R10 PL (c/s over Patritoic 337/350). New find Aug 15. Have pics. Bought by John Wilson at ANA from ST's first partner. Will need to tweak the intro - the Wilsons' piece may have been c/s in 1863 or so. Although 337 & 350 are undated; they are usually paired with 1863 dated patriotic dies (and business strikes). |
| 364 | NY-845A | town should be "Seneca Falls" |
| 366 | NY-890B | die 30900G is a later die state than 30900F. Correct the -12b and -38b listings from 30900G to 30900F, remove the picture of 30900G. Note in SC4 Word file to be added at p.368. |
| 366 | NY-890B | die 30900K pic - replace with one in SC3 pic file named 30900K per Bill. Bill reported wrong pic. Saved the correct one to scb3 photos file 2/29/16 |
| 366 | NY-890B | die 30900L pic - replace with one in SC3 pic file named 30900L per Bill. |
| 366 | NY-890B-36b (full brockage) | change die to 30910A/30910A inc |
| 366 | NY-890B-37b | change reverse to "incuse of Patriotic die 307" (and ditch the blank circle on page 368) |
| 366 | NY-890B-40b | change die to 30900B/30900B inc |
| 366 | NY-890B-42b (full brockage) | 30900J/30900J inc |
| 366 | NY-890B-43b (full brockage) | 30910C/30910C inc |
| 367 | die 30910H | replace current photo with photo named NY890B-9 rev replacement photo 30910H |
| 371 | NY-905B-2ao | enhance description - 1820 large cent |
| 371 | NY-905B-2ao1 | R10. Flipover double strike. Stacks sale of QDB inv. 10/20. |
| 373 | NY-990A-1a | change to reeded edge |
| 377 | OH-060C | header: change 31300 to 31290. |
| 377 | OH-060D-6b | should be "a" |
| 377 | OH-065-B-3z | Bill Luitje reported 5/24/18 that this is really lead., so change -3z to -3g and list above -3j. |
| 379 | OH-074A-1ao | R9. Not sure if this is even an overstrike. Have pics. Ex: Tanenbaum and sold by Steve Hayden 10/22. I don't see an understrike. |
| 379 | OH-074A-19a | R10 PL. 31410/36410 (reverse is obverse of OH-830D) |
| 380 | OH-100B | blue box: OH-165CY-110 & 113 |
| 382 | OH-120B-3a | R9 R. reported by Larry D. |
| 384 | OH-160B-2d | R10 PL. |
| 386 | OH-160G-7f | R10 PL. Hayden website sold 5/20. |
| 387 | OH-165B-1a | reverse should be 1386 |
| 388 | OH-165E-8a | R10. obv: 31785 1192 reverse, PL. Have pic for inclusion in SC4. New obv die with SALOON misspelled (actually the first obv that was corrected for all other varieties) |
| 389 | OH-165Ia-1b | change rarity to R-9 |
| 391 | OH-165L-10b | R10 PL, obv: 31881 rev: 31881 inc (full brockage). Saw one slabbed as -8b by NGC (MS64) |
| 393 | OH-165R-7d | R10, plain edge. Reported by QDB 10/14/19. |
| 393 | OH-165R-10d | change reverse to 1047. Stacks sale 10/20. |
| 394 | OH-165R-28d | obv:32030/rev:1047 R10 ? For edge. Hayden sale #36, ex:Fuld |
| 394 | OH-165R-29d | 32040/1069 R10 reeded edge. |
| 395 | OH-165W-9a | muled with 165GS, not GA |
| 397 | OH-165Z-10b | should be-10d and should be die 1069. |
| 398 | OH-165AF | moved to Covington, KY |
| 399 | OH-165AH-3 | now have a picture of 32285 in SC3 photos folder. Need a better die explosion and alter the wording of the note. |
| 399 | OH-165AH-3b1 | change to PL edge, 17mm (Hayden 50) |
| 399 | OH-165AH-11a | obverse is 32280, not 33280 |
| 400 | OH-165AK-3b | change rarity to NV. Highly unlikely 1069 in brass. |
| 400 | OH-165AL-1a1 | R10 to R9 |
| 401 | OH-165AMc | see SC4 word file for clean up of intro |
| 406 | OH-165BEa-1b | should be -1bo |
| 407 | OH-165BJ-22a | reverse 1019 R6 PL missing |
| 408 | OH-165BN-1ao | R9. flipover dbl strike |
| 409 | OH-165BO-6a | R9. ? for edge. Rev: 1008. Need to confirm existing "1009"s truly are that. -1a might be 1008 and no actual 1009. See email from Bill Luitje 12/19/16 and others. A copper version of 1008 definitely exists (have pics in an email). 1009 exists - Stacks Nov 2020 |
| 410 | OH-165BS-4d | R9. Second example reported by SH 11/6/20 |
| 411 | OH-165BV-15a1 | Should be PL edge. |
| 411 | OH-165BV-17a1 | Should be PL edge. |
| 411 | OH-165BV-20a | Incorrect die combination listed in the book; should be dies 32850/1437 |
| 412 | OH-165BZ-4a | rev should be 1418, not 1419, sold in Stacks sale 11/21 |
| 415 | OH-165CJ-11a | obv: should be 33080, not 33090 |
| 417 | OH-165CR-7d | change rarity to R-9 |
| 421 | OH-165CY-71b | change rarity rating from NV to R-9 |
| 421 | OH-165CY-80d | R10. PE. Reported by QDB 11/27/18. |
| 422 | OH-165CY-108d | reverse s/b 1331 |
| 423 | OH-165DB | picture is of die 33390 but says 33340 |
| 423 | OH-165DD-1a/b (?) | not currently listed, R10, Steve Hayden sold one June, 2013- need to verify. Owned by Mark Gatcha - can we examine the rim? Ernie think just a bad alloy mix. |
| 423 | OH-165DD-1b1 | edge s/b 'R' |
| 423 | OH-165DD-12a | new die 33435/1009. PL edge. (Die 33435-spacing between H of Hosiery and G of gloves most obvious). This die may have been used on others currently called 33430. The -9 varieties appear to all be the 33430 die. The -7a1 seem to be both. Need a die explosion. |
| 423 | OH-165DD-12a1 | new die 33435/1009. R edge. |
| 426 | OH-165DMa | New merchant: R10, rev: 1374A, pl edge, 19mm. Call the obverse die 33555. See SC4 word file for write-up. |
| 428 | OH-165DT-6a | change rarity to R-9 |
| 430 | OH-16DX-2b | new variety, counterstamped 45, blank reverse, hole. Reported by David Zimmerman. Have pics. See emails late Oct from QDB. This has a different obv & rev. Possibly the circulation strike. |
| 430 | OH-16DX | photo should be labeled 33660 |
| 430 | OH-165DY | Replace last line of narrative with verbiage at SC4 word file |
| 430 | OH-165DY-13b | This variety is probably post war - Murdock was a sole proprietor at 139 W. 5th c.1870-74. Remove this listing and the 22015 and 33710 die photos as well. |
| 430 | OH-165DZ | narrative - change last sentence - see SC4 word file |
| 431 | OH-165EB-8a | R9 PL. (reverse is incuse federal Indian cent). Ex: Bowers, Hayden 47 |
| 432 | OH-165ED-2a | change to PL edge |
| 437 | OH-165EV-6b | change rarity to R-9 |
| 437 | OH-165EW-2a | change edge to PL |
| 442 | OH-165FR-1d | change to reeded edge |
| 443 | OH-165FV-1a | R9. Currently listed as R8, but I know of only one and same for SLT. See email from QDB 10/15/19. |
| 444 | OH-165FX-11i | R9 Reeded edge. New variety. |
| 444 | OH-165FX-16i | R9. |
| 445 | OH-165FXa-5b | R9. pl edge. New variety |
| 447 | OH-165GB | change photo label from 34430 to 34440 |
| 447 | OH-165GC-3b | R9 PL. Stacks Naples Bay collection lot 3108 11/20. |
| 448 | OH-165GH | -9d listing says FX instead of GH |
| 449 | OH-165GI-10a | R9 PL. Also change both -10 varieties to reverse 1426. unlisted in copper. B&M 11/99 Lot 3229. |
| 449 | OH-165GI-12a | R9 OL. 34510/1420. new variety reported by Steve Hayden email 7/20/17. |
| 451 | OH-165GP-3a | R8. |
| 451 | OH-165GR-1ao | R9. Have seen two examples. |
| 452 | OH-165GS-29a | R7 PL 34630/1029. Photo from Tim Webb 10/22 |
| 453 | OH-165GX-1a | change edge to PL |
| 454 | OH-165GY-32e | 18mm, R-9 per Hayden 47 |
| 455 | OH-175C-13a | 75/525 should be 73/525 (R4) |
| 455 | OH-175C | -16 and -7 appear to be redundant listings - remove and leave a note that -16 varieties are actually -7 |
| 455 | OH-175C | -17 and -10 appear to be redundant listings - remove and leave note that -17 variety is actually -10 |
| 455 | OH-175C-18a | Reverse die should be 40040, not 40030. Should say reverse instead of obverse. |
| 455 | OH-175C-19d | obv is 35030 |
| 459 | OH-175O | intro paragraph - remove second to last sentence stating that OH-175O-4r in aluminum is a post-war strike. |
| 459 | OH-175O-4r | change to plain edge |
| 459 | OH-175P-2a | R9 |
| 460 | OH-175S-4do | R9 |
| 460 | OH-175S-15a | New Unlisted die combination of 35300/1172. R10, PL |
| 461 | OH-185A-6a1 | R9 reeded edge. missing |
| 462 | OH-200B-2f | R10 PL. Presidential sale #56 6/94 and again in Bowers & Merena 11/95. Hayden 50 |
| 465 | OH-230B-2a1 | reverse s/b 1023 |
| 465 | OH-230B-7a1 | R9 PL. Reported by QDB 2/25/18. |
| 466 | OH-270A | merchant surname should be spelled "Farnham" in the merchant header |
| 467 | OH-300A | Remove listing. Leave behind a blue box. Boger & Kimmel - moved to NC section as OH-OH-Aa. Mark B.'s research shows business commenced 7/14/1865. CWTS article |
| 472 | OH-360A-1a | change rarity to R8 |
| 473 | OH-360B-5a | R9. Hayden 47 mentioned a second example. |
| 476 | OH-420A-1a | change edge to PL |
| 476 | OH-420A-1d | R10 PL. new composition. Reported by Steve H. 9/3/20 |
| 477 | OH-445A-3a | Rev: 1086A. I don't know where this came from. Probably QDB.- email tp Bill Luitje 12/18/23 |
| 478 | OH-562 becomes OH 495A | move OH-562 George Haines; butcher to here and recatalog as OH-495A Madison Township. All 562 become 495. See SC4 word file for new intro. |
| 478 | OH-505A-2a | change from R edge to PL |
| 478 | OH-505B-5b | R8 PL missing |
| 479 | OH-530A | photo label s/b 35670 |
| 479 | OH-535A-4a | Rev: 1086A. I don't know where this came from. Probably QDB.- email tp Bill Luitje 12/18/23 |
| 479 | OH-535A-11a | R9 PL. 35710/1085. Pics from Tim Webb 10/22. Steve and Tim agreed that it is 35710 and the period after OHIO just weakly struck or die polished. |
| 480 | OH-535B-4a | R9 PL. 35475/1169 |
| 482 | OH-555A-4a1 | R9 PL, new variety reported by Dave Bowers. |
| 482 | OH-557A-5d | R10. Reeded edge. Tanenbaum collection. |
| 483 | OH-562 | George Haines; butcher. Move to Madison Township as OH-495A |
| 485 | OH-620A-13a | R10 PL. Rev: 1427D. reported by Larry D. |
| 487 | OH-670A | correct the header to Timmins |
| 490 | OH-735B-1d | R9. |
| 490 | OH-735B | photo label s/b 36160 |
| 491 | OH-745A-1d | R9. QDB reported another 10/24/17. Remove note about ANS collection. |
| 491 | OH-745A-2b(fp) | Change from NV to R-9. One in an NCS holder (ex: Bleviss) sold 4/18. |
| 497 | OH-830C | picture of die should be labeled 36400 |
| 497 | OH-830C-9b | rev: 1023A. R10, reeded edge. Reported by Steve Hayden 10/30/17. This is actually rev 1031 (variety -2b), so we are good to go. No change needed. |
| 497 | OH-830D-6a | Change rarity from NV to R-9. Susan reported one with a reeded edge 2/24/18. Purchased from Cade years ago. |
| 506 | OH-910aA-2a | should be 39130/39130 inc |
| 507 | OH-915B-1a | change reverse to 1179 |
| 507 | OH-915B-2a | change reverse to 1178 and rarity rating to NV. |
| 507 | OH-925A-1d | R10 reeded edge missing |
| 510 | OH-975A-1bo | R10 PL (flip over double strike). Tim Webb pics 6/23. 21mm - for all Beach tokens. |
| 511 | OH-975C-5a | change rarity to R-9. At least three known. |
| 512 | OH-975G | Change header to Grocer from Saloon |
| 514 | OH-975O | change Made by John Stanton to Lanphear shop, Cincinnati. |
| 518 | PA-013C-1a | reverse die s/b 1028 |
| 518 | PA-013C-7a | R9 Pl edge. Rev: 1192 |
| 521 | PA-360A-1do | correct from -1d to -1do |
| 523 | PA-750A | Replace intro with that at SC4 word file. |
| 524 | PA-750E-2 | change all metals from 1150 to 1150B. Hayden sold one Dec 2016. |
| 525 | PA-750F-2a | should be 750F-1d |
| 526 | PA-750La | remove Hagan's. To be listed in possible CWT section under PA. p.640. |
| 529 | PA-750P-2a | reverse is 40410 inc |
| 529 | PA-750P-4j | reverse is 40420 inc |
| 530 | PA-750T-1d | R10 reeded edge. new variety reported by Steve Hayden, QDB collection; email 10/16/17. |
| 531 | PA-750V-1a(fp) | R9 PL. Stacks sale Nov 2019, Lot 20417. Donated in 1897. |
| 531 | PA-750V-7a | R10. Reeded edge. ex: Bowers, Hayden 47. |
| 532 | PA-750W-2a | change from NV to R-9. NGC has attributed one as copper; see email 6/19/17 from John Esterly |
| 532 | PA-765B | photo label s/b 40720 |
| 533 | PA-765E-7a | R9. reeded edge, new variety. |
| 539 | PA-967A | header should read 'Greenville' with two Ls |
| 542 | RI-700D-13a | 42055/42025. R10 PL. per QDB 2/22/18. Also Hayden website $450 Apr 2014. |
| 545 | RI-700I-2a | R10. PL. 42132/42140. |
| 546 | TN-130A-3d | R9 (one known outside ANS collection; sold in Stacks 6/17). Remove note about ANS collection. |
| 548 | TN-600A-8i | R10 PL edge. |
| 548 | TN-600A-10b1 | change rarity rating to R9 per QDB 5/16/18. Remove note about ANS collection. |
| 548 | TN-600A-14a | R10 PL. reverse: 1419. Incorr slabbed by PCGS as -2a. Bill sent link 4/14/19. |
| 548 | TN-600B-1b | R10 PL. reported by Larry Dziubek. 8/10/21. |
| 548 | TN-600B-2b | R10 PL. reported by QDB 9/24/19. |
| 548 | TN-600B-14a | R10 PL. reverse: 1419 source: QDB 9/20/17. |
| 550 | TN-600C-4b | R10 new variety. Stacks sale Apr 2021 ex: Bowers. Reeded edge. |
| 550 | TN-600G-1b1 | obv: 43136. R9 PL. Stacks sale July 2020. Have pic at SC3 die photos. |
| 550 | TN-600G-1b2 | obv: 43137. R9 PL. Stacks sale July 2020. Have pic at SC3 die photos. |
| 551 | TN-690D-6bo | change OH-165AY to OH-557A |
| 551 | TN-690D-6j | R10. RE. QDB sale Aug 2018. |
| 551 | TN-690D-9j | R10. RE. Reported by QDB 1/15/18. |
| 552 | TN-690E-8do | Correct attribution should be 690E-8d. Remove comment about struck over CN cent. This is not overstruck, but is rotated double struck. |
| 552 | TN-690E-9do | Correct attribution should be 690E-9d. This piece is not overstruck. |
| 555 | WV-100B-2b | R10, unlisted composition, reeded edge (source QDB 10/2/17) |
| 555 | WV-100B-1e through 7e | R10. RE in WM. $2 & $5 sent photos by Larry Dziubek 5/10/21. 1881 auction catalog on my computer from QDB. |
| 555 | WV-100B-8 through 14 | Change all -8 through 14 from 1046 to 1046A. Stacks 11/20 ex: Bleviss, incorr slabbed as -5d. |
| 556 | WV-260A-2b | R9, reeded edge. unlisted composition. eBay sale 12/15 |
| 563 | WI-220A | photo is wrong. Have a replacement picture of 220A in SCB3 photos folder. |
| 564 | WI-220F-3a | reverse s/b 1168 |
| 567 | WI-250F | all listings have 250E, change to 250F |
| 568 | | note to explain where "250H" is (as in SC2) |
| 572 | WI-330B | change merchant header to grocer |
| 575 | WI-410G-7a | change obverse/reverse to: 45815/45800 |
| 577 | WI-420A-1do | change rarity to NV. The slabbed example was not struck over anything. Stacks Nov 2020. |
| 581 | WI-510I | listings have 510A, change all to 510I |
| 582 | WI-510M | header change to - Goes and Falk |
| 582 | WI-510N | header - change spelling to 'Hantzsch' as depicted on token |
| 583 | WI-510P | header change from 'business unknown' to butcher |
| 583 | WI-510Q | narrative-change to Madison, Watertown & Milwaukee (from Milwaukee, Watertown, & Madison) |
| 584 | WI-510V | name spelling should be Kleinsteuber. Change narrative to language in SC4 word file. |
| 587 | WI-510AB-7b | R9 PL 33mm. Call obv: 46455 and new reverse 46465. obv: slightly different than 46450, reverse: 1/2 GALL. Reported by Bill Luitje 5/26/19. Pics in SC3 photos file. Need a die explosion for the obverse. |
| 589 | WI-510AK | header should read '& Son", not & Co. |
| 590 | WI-510AP-3a | change description: 46640 inc/1155. obverse is a brockage, rev: 1155 (see Hayden #46, 4/18) |
| 590 | WI-510AP-6a1 | R7, not R9. |
| 591 | WI-530A | header says IN-530, change to WI |
| 596 | WI-620O | header says IN-620, change to WI |
| 597 | WI-700A-6a | R9 PL. 47630/1098. New variety. |
| 597 | WI-700A-7a | R9 PL. 47630/1357. New variety. |
| 599 | WI-700I-4a | R9 PL. Obv 47720 Rev: 1203. Steve Hayden sold one on eBay 11/17. |
| 600 | WI-720A-1a1 | R9 PL. new variety |
| 606 | WI-920L-2b | correct variety for the hoard in the narrative to -2b (not -1a). |
| 609 | LU-C | 99040 & 99050 pictures should be flipped. Consulere is the obverse and is paired with 1046 (C-1a). |
| 609 | LU-C-2a1 | R9 PL. Reported by QDB 11/14/18. |
| 610 | LU-E | move to Paducah, KY? |
| 610 | LU-E-2d | change edge to PL |
| 610 | LU-E-3b | change rarity to NV. Highly unlikely 1042 paired with a Lanphear obverse. |
| 610 | LU-Ea-g(ap) | Day's New Card. See SC4 word file for write-up. |
| 611 | LU-G & J move | Move these to where they belong. And leave behind a blue box. LU-G moved to MI-225AGa and LU-J moved to KY-510Ga. |
| 611 | LU-I | move to IN-200A Crawsfordsville, IN (new town) and leave behind a blue box. |
| 611 | LU-I-4b | should be R9 (I know of 2) Now IN-200A-4b. |
| 611 | LU-Ka-1a | Professor King tokens. See SC4 Word file |
| 612 | LU-N | May be copper. Review pics. There is a new variety as well. Have a pictures now. Fix the presentation of photos. 99250/99270 should be side by side as well as 99260/99280. I have a pic of 99260 with No. 42 instead of No. 5. New die or not? |
| 612 | LU-O | Change description to Stanton shop, Cincinnati. |
| 612 | LU-O-1b | change rarity to NV |
| 613 | LU-R | Lott should be Lot |
| 613 | LU-S-6d | R10 reeded edge. Reverse 1018. Ex-Tanenbaum, owned by Steve Hayden. |
| 613 | LU-S-7b | R9 reeded edge. obv: 99355, rev: 1398A. new variety - 25c. Reverse to Town Branch Store. Hayden#42 lot 368; obverse is also a different variety. Have pics. This variety is 22mm. Have pics - need to insert into SC4. |
| 615 | IL-150Ha | remove listing and change blue box to - IL-150Ha Buck & Rayner see possible Civil War token section. |
| 616 | MD-060Ua-1h-bla | R9. PL. 48200/48210. 23mm. See SC4 word file for write-up. |
| 617 | MA-115Fa | Header should read, "also known as"; not "formerly known as" |
| 617 | MA-115Fb | Header should read, "also known as"; not "formerly known as" |
| 618 | MA-115H | Header should read, "also known as"; not "formerly known as" |
| 618 | MA-970C-1h | Larry reports a second reverse die in an email 1/31/17. Need pics. Larry reports 7/3/17-in a survey of 8; 3 of 'a' variety and 5 of 'b' variety. I have a pdf of two different scans dated 9/14/21. May need pics. SH has one on his website, but it is same variety as in SC3. |
| 618 | MO-910aA | See SC4 word file. General Eastern Railroad, Schenkman G5 included in an 1863 auction. I show we decided to list this (decision #173). Must have just missed it. Schenkman article confirms 1863 auction listing (Fall 2021). |
| 619 | NY-010Da-1h-bla | R9 new variety in black. Heritage 6/16 |
| 620 | NY-630Ka | change how the dies photos are arranged so that obv and rev are left and right instead of top and bottom. 29282/28286 left/right. 29284/29288 (have pics). |
| 620 | NY-630Ka | die 29288 is the same as die 30387 (Shiffer obv). Can copy picture to where needed on page 620 and change the die # at Shiffer. |
| 621 | NY-630AGa | add Samuel Hart & Co. rubber token. See SC4 word file for write-up. |
| 621 | NY-630BIa | pics 32044, 32045, 32046, & 32047 s/b rectangular, not square - have improvement pics for 1st two, can the other two be stretched? |
| 622 | NY-630BQa | pics 30384 & 30385 s/b rectangular, not square - have improvement pics |
| 622 | NY-630BQa-2h | change rarity rating to R9 |
| 623 | NY-630BQb-1h | Change die 30387 to die 29288 (Broadway Rubber reverse). Same die. Use whichever pic is superior and label as such. |
| 623 | NY-630CK-1h-bro | R9. Unlisted in brown and also unl in Schenkman. Have photos 3/10/15 |
| 624 | NY-890D-2hbla | Second obv die - 30965 in SC3 photos file. Need to do a die "explosion" to show difference. Spacing between T and S of FIRST ST. Photos from Tim Webb 6/23. R8? |
| 624 | NY-890D-2hbro | Second obv die - 30965 in SC3 photos file. Need to do a die "explosion" to show difference. Spacing between T and S of FIRST ST. Photos from Tim Webb 10/22. R8? |
| 625 | OH-200Ga | Smith & Conrad, Columbus, OH rubber token. Consider inclusion. See Schenkman's article Vol 54 #3, Fall 2020. |
| 625 | PA-750H-2h | R6. per Larry Dziubek |
| 626 | PA-765Qa-2h | R9. per Larry Dziubek |
| 628 | NC-LU-B | Eureka tokens, omitted by accident. Add some sort of narrative (have something in the SC4 word file) and change index from LU-C to LU-B |
| 629 | NC-OH-Aa | Boger & Kimmel. Findlay. See write up in SC4 word file. |
| 629 | NC-OH-B | add the words "the war" to the end of the sentence at NC-OH-B |
| 629 | NC-OH-E | see SC4 word file for better write-up |
| 632 | NC-WI-Ba | add a listing for the 1867 dated Charles Kleinsteuber pieces. 1867 WM (like die 46340). Have a narrative in the SC4 word file. |
| 633+ | | see SC4 word file for additions to the possible CWT section |
| 637 | | Remove Colburn listing. Should have been in the main listing. |
| 638 | Day | Remove Day (Fuld Patriotic #476) listing. Now in the LU section. |
| 639 | see SC4 Word file | Possible CWT - Pennypacker & Sibley (Miller Pa 390 & 391)- probably Van Wert, OH per SH auction #40 c.1863-70. |
| 640 | Possible CWT section | PA-750La Hagan's - see write-up in SC4 Word file |
| 640 | Charles K. Warner | attribution should be "Ph" not "Oh" |
| 641 | Possible CWT section | remove Perrin from Wisconsin and "Wisconsin"- was not listed in Janesville in the 1865/6 WI gazetteer |
| 646 | | add Great Eastern - see SC4 word file |
| 647 | | add William P. Mullen, prison agent dated 1862, Phil. Page 350 Rulau 4th. Miller 616A. See SC4 word file. |
| 649 | index | can we list all merchants including DNL,NC and possible CWT section??? About 120 possible CWTs and 80 DNLs. |
| 653 | | Eureka is NC-LU-B |
| 661 | MD-060-AL Stevens | remove reference. Does not exist in main text. |
